The indictment, handed down Monday, alleges Mark Hunt and defendants stole 9 properties from their lawful owners
BY AMELIA FERRELL KNISELY AND HENRY CULVYHOUSE
West Virginia Auditor Mark Hunt, a Republican elected in 2024, is under scrutiny for personally signing tax deeds for a friend. (Photo by Perry Bennett/West Virginia Legislative Photography)
What state Auditor Mark Hunt called a “tempest in a teapot” has turned into a federal indictment.
A federal grand jury Monday handed up multi-count indictments against Hunt and Charleston-area lawyer Robert L. Johns related to nine tax delinquent deeds Hunt signed for Johns.
Federal prosecutors said Hunt, 66, of Charleston, overruled career employees at the Auditor’s Office and issued the deeds after they found Johns had not complied with the law.
Hunt told West Virginia Watch that Johns was a longtime friend and downplayed any legal issues associated with the transfers.
“The rules governing public office are not optional. They do not change based on who you know, who your friends are or what position you hold,” said U.S. Attorney Moore Capito at a news conference on Monday. “The integrity of public institutions depends on public officials faithfully carrying out their responsibilities. As alleged, the state auditor violated that trust.”
Capito’s office announced the indictments on Monday, stating that signing the deeds amounted to theft.
“As a result of the scheme, the defendants stole the nine properties from their lawful owners, the indictments allege,” the office wrote.
In a Facebook post on Monday, Hunt said he is “innocent of these charges.”
“The indictment is an insult to the principles on which this country was founded. An indictment is only an allegation. I am presumed innocent and I will vigorously defend myself against these charges,” Hunt wrote.
Hunt and Johns have been charged with nine counts of theft of more than $5,000 by a public official, for which Hunt faces up to 10 years in prison for each count.
Hunt has also been charged with one count of bank fraud, for which he could face up to 30 years in prison.
The grand jury also issued indictments against employees in Hunt’s office, including Deputy Chief of Staff David Cole, 57, of Charleston, who a West Virginia Watch investigation revealed was running a car lot with Hunt. Federal authorities say Cole and another member of staff, Frederic Caudill, 59, of Charleston, helped create the deeds.
Cole and Caudill were both charged with nine counts of theft of more than $5,000 by a public official. Cole also received one count of bank fraud.
They’ve also been charged with a count of lying to FBI agents during the investigation, for which they could face up to five years in prison.
Cole told investigators that he did not remember Hunt signing the deeds, nor did he recall Hunt holding a roundtable meeting about the issue, according to the indictment.
Caudill also told investigators that he didn’t remember the deeds, court records show. He also denied asking, “Who’s going to be the whistleblower?” when an employee raised concerns about the issue, the indictment stated.
The bank fraud stems from Marie Hoffman, 66, of Hurricane — also charged with bank fraud — working at Hunt’s private law office while on state working hours and receiving a check for those hours.
The indictments state that Hunt and Cole worked with Hoffman on Friday afternoons between May 2025 and September 2026 at Hunt’s private law office. Hunt was aware of the time-theft and Cole approved falsified time cards, according to the indictment.
All five defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law, Moore said.
“But the notion that you know that an elected official would feel so empowered to be cavalier about the application of what is rather clear law, I think is, you know, is disappointing to me as a West Virginian,” Moore told reporters. “Quite frankly, I think we expect our public officials and those that lead this state to do so with not only transparency, transparency and candor, but with integrity.”
Hunt, a Republican, has served as the state auditor since 2025. He is an attorney with Mark A. Hunt & Associates PLLC, where he has continued to practice law while working as a state official.
By Monday afternoon, House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, R-Clay, called on Hunt to resign.
Hunt indicated he has no plans to resign as of now.
“I remain focused on the work of the Auditor’s Office and will continue to serve the people of West Virginia while the matter is resolved in court,” Hunt wrote on Facebook.
Before the federal indictment announcement, lawmakers on both sides of the aisle had also called on Hunt to resign due to his handling of property deeds for Johns.
In late October, Brad McElhinny of WV MetroNews reported that the Auditor’s Office was served a federal grand jury subpoena.
Hunt said last week that he didn’t know the subject of that investigation.
The FBI and the West Virginia Commission on Special Investigations investigated the case.
















